You’ve been paying in year after year. After year. After year. And paying double on top of that. Over fifteen percent of your income has been going towards Social Security since you entered the ministry. When does it all pay off? When do you start receiving the benefits?

You can file for and begin receiving your Social Security retirement benefits any time between ages 62 and 70. However, what you receive at age 62 is vastly different than what you would receive at age 70.

Primary Insurance Amount

When determining your Social Security retirement benefits, the Social Security Administration (SSA) starts by looking at your earnings history. Your highest 35 years of earnings, to be exact. The index your earnings to account for inflation and come up with your “averaged indexed monthly earnings.” How much money did you make while you were working? 

It adjusts every year for inflation, but for someone turning 62 in 2021, the first $996 of averaged indexed monthly earnings provides a 90% benefit and the next $5,006 of averaged indexed monthly earnings provides a 3% benefit. As such, very low-income earners can earn as much as 90% of their average earnings for their retirement benefit.

The earnings from which retirement benefits are calculated are capped. In 2021, the cap is $142,800. Anything above that does not increase your retirement benefit. The highest possible benefit that someone can have earned is $3,895 per month for 2021. 

What they calculate based on your earnings history is called your Primary Insurance Amount (PIA).

Full Retirement Age

I mentioned that you can collect retirement benefits any time between the ages of 62 and 70, but there is one specific age that the SSA considers your full retirement age (FRA). It is based on your date of birth as laid out in the chart below:

Your FRA is when you are eligible for the PIA I explained above. I know, it’s starting to look like a middle schooler’s text feed with so many acronyms. Would you prefer I write them out?

When you reach your full retirement age you are eligible for your primary insurance amount. But what happens if your full retirement age is 67 and you want to start collecting at age 62? They decrease your benefit amount. The primary insurance amount is decreased by 5/9 of 1% for each month you claim early, up to 36 months. If you claim even earlier, then it is reduced 5/12 of 1% per month. For example, if your full retirement age is 67 and you claim benefits at age 62, your PIA is reduced by 30%.

It works in reverse as well. Your primary insurance amount is increased by 8% for every year you wait to collect benefits after your full retirement age. Only until age 70, though. There is no benefit in waiting any longer.

How To Decide When To Claim Benefits

Things are set up so that whenever you begin collecting benefits, whether age 62, 70, or some time in between, if you live the average life expectancy you will collect the same total amount over your lifetime. The break-even point where it all evens out is around age 82 or 83.

So, is there an optimal time to start collecting retirement benefits? 

That will depend on your own unique situation. Often when we do an analysis, it turns out best to wait as long as possible to increase the monthly benefit amount. One of the reasons for that is that when one spouse passes away, the surviving spouse gets to collect the greater of either his or her own benefit or the deceased spouse’s benefit. For that reason, in situations where one spouse’s earned benefit is much higher than the other’s (as is usually the case for a pastor who has opted out of Social Security but has an eligible spouse), it is often best for the higher-earning spouse to wait to maximize their benefit.

Another thing to take into consideration is your health and family history. If you have health problems or a family history of shorter lifespans, you may be better off collecting benefits sooner. 

What is best for you? I wouldn’t know for sure unless I looked at your exact numbers and even then, I have no way of knowing when God will call you home. None of us do, so you just have to make the best decision possible with the information that you do have.