When Should A Pastor Request A Housing Allowance?

by

Any time you want tax-free housing!

While that answer is true, here is an excerpt from my book, The Pastor’s Wallet Complete Guide to the Clergy Housing Allowance, that will provide a bit more depth: 

Timing

Timing is very important when it comes to the housing allowance. A housing allowance can only be paid prospectively, not retroactively. That means you cannot go back in time. You can only take a housing allowance after it has been designated; any expenses incurred prior to the official designation are ineligible.

That is why leaving the designation open-ended is a good idea. Then you don’t have to worry about missing out on the housing allowance because you forgot to get it officially designated on time. You know you will always have it available to you and you only need to worry about the amount rather than the timing.

Many churches designate housing allowances by the calendar year since that is how most pastors file their taxes. If that is how your church does it, you should make sure to request your allowance in December of the prior year so that there is time for it to be officially designated before the start of the new year. 

Nonetheless, you can actually request a housing allowance at any time during the calendar year. The IRS has no restrictions on timing other than requiring the designation to be provided in advance of payment. So, if you enter the ministry or change churches in August, you should request your housing allowance immediately instead of waiting until the next January.

Changing Your Housing Allowance

Also, you can change your housing allowance at any time. If your housing situation changes dramatically mid-year, you can request a new housing allowance designation that will reflect that. For example, you purchase a home in June after having lived in a cheap apartment. You should request a higher housing allowance at the end of May in preparation for your move. 

The higher housing allowance amount would only apply to your expenses in June and thereafter. All of your housing costs up until the new designation would still only qualify for the lower, previous designated allowance. In this kind of situation, you would have to calculate your housing expenses for the two separate time periods, January through May and June through December. If you found at the end of the year that you had excess housing allowance from the second half of the year, you would not be able to use it for expenses from the first half of the year. 

Backdating A Housing Allowance

Sometimes, a church will fail to designate a housing allowance in a timely manner and they may want to backdate a resolution or pass one retroactively to allow a pastor to have previous expenses covered. That is illegal. Wrong. Bad. Not allowed. A SIN!

Knowing falsification of such a document is a crime under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. There is no exemption for churches and pastors under the act and penalties range from fines to imprisonment. Aside from the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, such behavior is subject to civil or criminal penalties under the tax code. Just don’t go there. Pay the taxes and learn your lesson for next time.

If you want to learn more about the clergy housing allowance, pick up a copy of The Pastor’s Wallet Complete Guide to the Clergy Housing Allowance on Amazon today!

Purchase The Complete Guide to the Clergy Housing Allowance by Amy Artiga
0
7 Responses
  • Art Lemire
    March 29, 2021

    Can you publish an article on how a Pastor should handle living in a parsonage at no cost – our church offers a nice home plus utilities to our Pastor at no cost – we do not have a mortgage on the property !

    • Amy
      March 30, 2021

      Art, what specific points would you like to see addressed in an article like that?

  • Lawrence A Gember
    March 29, 2021

    Great article! It prompted me to read your entire book (on Amazon) on this subject. I read the whole book today and highly recommend it to others! It is much easier to understand than other books I have read.
    I was prompted by the comment in this article that you could change your housing allowance designation mid-year but you should do it before incurring the actual housing expense. That case was for someone actively employed at a church. I retired from church ministry in April 2020 (after 35 years as ordained minister) but now work a secular job and fill in at local churches to preach and administer Holy Communion at Sunday worship maybe once every six weeks. I have not yet taken any money from my denomination’s 403b even though I am 66 and eligible. Since 100% of that 403b money is eligible to be considered housing allowance, can I wait till the end of 2021 to see what my housing expenses have actually been, and then request a distribution equal to that amount? Your book does not directly deal with that question but it seems implied that this would be legal.
    It also appears from reading your book that since I will receive more that $600 from one church this year for filling in on Sundays, that I can have them designate 100% that $200/per Sunday honorarium as housing and they will not have to issue a 1099 at the end of 2021. Is that correct?

  • Amy
    March 30, 2021

    I’m glad that you enjoyed the book, Lawrence! The law says that the housing allowance must be designated in advance, but it does not say that it must be paid in advance. I don’t see anything wrong with having all 403(b) distributions designated as housing allowance but waiting until the end of the year to actually decide how much of a distribution to take. Since you are of retirement age but still working, you are in a position to take advantage of some unique financial planning opportunities, such as taking the full housing allowance from your 403(b) and contributing to a Roth IRA, which in essence moves money from a tax-deferred account to a tax-free account without having to pay taxes.

    If the church where you fill in designates all of your income as a housing allowance, then you are correct, they do not have to report anything to the IRS and issue a 1099. The IRS is only notified of that money when you file Schedule SE (if you have not opted out of Social Security).

  • Shannon
    September 9, 2021

    When a loan (or revolving credit) is being used for a house improvement, what amount is applied when? When the total expense is incurred, or as the payments are being made?

    • Amy
      September 10, 2021

      Shannon, I haven’t seen this addressed specifically, but unless it is a Home Equity Line of Credit, I would think when the expense is incurred. The only loan payments that I have seen eligible for the housing allowance are mortgage and HELOC payments. Otherwise, it would be like when you buy something on a credit card. The housing allowance is applied when you make the purchase, not when you pay the credit card.

      • Shannon
        September 16, 2021

        Thank you, Amy!

What do you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.